This episode has been a long time coming. I first came across Isle of Raasay Distillery through Travel Bar and Drammers back in 2023, when I got to taste through the Na Sia component series and see just how differently the same spirit was developing across their rye, Bordeaux, and Chinkapin casks. That was when the Na Sia was between three and four years old.
A few years and several more Raasay releases later, I finally got to sit down with co-founder and Master Distiller Alasdair Day.
Raasay itself is tiny, about 14 miles long and three miles wide, almost exactly the dimensions of Manhattan, with a population that has only recently started creeping toward 200. You get there by taking a ferry from Skye, and the distillery is now the island’s largest employer, with roughly 40 people working across production, warehousing, bottling, tours, accommodation, the restaurant, and the bar.
Alasdair and co-founder Bill Dobbie wanted to build a distillery, and the ferry infrastructure made Raasay viable in a way it hadn’t been before. But when they presented the plans to the community, older residents told them that creating real careers could give younger people a reason to come home rather than leaving the island for university or work and never returning. That story has come up a number of times before, most similarly at Isle of Harris, which is relatively nearby and also in the Hebrides. The distillery first hired locally, then reached the point where people began moving to Raasay specifically to work there.
Alasdair’s route there started at almost the opposite end of Scotland. His great-grandfather was a whisky blender in Coldstream in the Scottish Borders, and in 2009 Alasdair inherited the family cellar book containing blends produced from 1899 through 1916. His father handed it over with the fairly straightforward instruction that he had to do something with it, which eventually became The Tweeddale blend.
As mature whisky became harder to source around 2012 and 2013, Alasdair started doing the math on buying new make and laying down his own stock. At some point he realized the amount of money required was close to what was required to build a small distillery. He met Bill while raising investment, visited Raasay in 2014, stood outside the disused hotel that would become the distillery looking across toward Skye and the Cuillin, and the decision was made.
Designing the Whisky Backwards
One of the best (and scariest) parts of building a new distillery where one hasn’t existed before is that there is no inherited house or regional style to protect. This was the island’s first legal distillery, so Alasdair could start with the whisky he wanted to drink and work backward into the equipment and process required to make it. There was probably some illicit distilling on the island, but the population was so small that it’s unlikely to have ever been at significant scale.
He settled on light peat and dark fruit as the broad Raasay profile, drawing some inspiration from other Hebridean distilleries while looking for something that could become recognizable on its own. Old Bowmore, pre-70s shift, was a particular inspiration, though I’d never liken Raasay to Bowmore. Alasdair came into the project as a blender, not an industry veteran, which I think freed him from several mental and layout restraints. Rather than making one new make spirit and expecting casks to provide all the variation, Raasay can change quite a few things before the spirit ever reaches wood.
They produce both peated and unpeated spirit, use three- and five-day fermentations, can control fermentation temperatures, and have a wash still setup that allows them to redirect heavier vapors back toward the pot for additional copper contact and heat. There’s also a six-plate purifier on the spirit still that can be brought into play when they want a much cleaner, lighter, darker-fruit-driven spirit.
We went fairly deep into the chemistry here, including yeast autolysis after the main fermentation, lactobacillus taking over during the longer fermentation, ester development, copper reactions, and even a little Maillard reaction on the wash still. This is where Alasdair’s botany background starts showing itself. He can happily go from talking about building a distillery to discussing long-chain esters and oak taxonomy without much warning. If you’re into the chemistry, the dendrology, and overall nerdy details, I highly encourage you to sign up for Alasdair’s SubStack. Raasay has several opportunities to push the spirit lighter, heavier, fruitier, or oilier while keeping it within the flavor range they designed from the beginning. Their much more unusual 3.4-times-distilled release showed just how far they can take the purifier, but most of those variables are used more subtly in the core whisky.
They also experimented with growing barley on Raasay from 2017 through 2019. Commercial Concerto barley grew but couldn’t ripen within the island’s May-to-August growing season, while Bere barley and short-season varieties from Iceland and Norway performed much better. They eventually filled nine casks from those trials, and Alasdair says the whisky still tastes recognizably Raasay while being clearly different from their normal spirit. Those casks are staying put for now, but I’m keeping an eye on them…
The farming work has continued at their property outside Campbeltown, at Macrihanish, where they’ve grown both Laureate and Bere barley. Bere has proven more challenging there because the farm basically sits in an Atlantic wind tunnel, which is less than ideal for a tall, top-heavy heritage barley. Similar problems have been reported by American rye growers who want the heritage grains with plump heads that are liable to lodging during a windstorm. They have also worked with a grower in Berwickshire, where the climate is considerably friendlier and where Raasay has already bottled its first Bere barley single cask.
Six (Casks), Seven (Years Later)
The Raasay whisky I first tasted in 2023 was built around the six-cask recipe central to the distillery: peated and unpeated spirit matured separately in ex-rye, fresh Chinkapin oak, and ex-Bordeaux red wine casks, then brought back together.
The rye choice was partly an attempt to get away from the ex-bourbon default and bring black pepper alongside the vanilla and butterscotch of American oak. Bordeaux supplies the dark fruit Alasdair was chasing from the beginning, with left-bank Cabernet Sauvignon casks bringing plenty of fruit and tannin before the spirit eventually works its way deeper into the French oak.
Chinkapin is probably the most unusual piece. Raasay has been using fresh Chinkapin for full-term maturation since the beginning, with a very specific combination of long air-drying, heavy toast, and heavy char. It brings richness without flattening the spirit and, in Alasdair’s view, ties the other cask styles together. As far as I’m aware, Raasay is the only distillery using full-maturation Chinkapin at scale.
Raasay has kept parcels of those six component casks aside for the Na Sia series, releasing them at three, five, and now seven years old, with nine- and eleven-year versions still to come. It gives us an unusually direct look at how each part of the original recipe is aging.
Some have changed more than Alasdair expected. The ex-rye casks needed time and are only now really coming into their own at seven years. Chinkapin was the star almost immediately at three and five, but by seven the oak is becoming more assertive. The peated Bordeaux has gone the other way and is becoming one of Alasdair’s favorites, showing more of the maritime, dark-fruited profile he hoped the distillery would develop.
The Na Sia series itself was basically a COVID accident. Before Raasay had even launched its first single malt, they bottled small samples of the six young components for virtual tastings. People kept coming back as those casks aged because they wanted to see what had changed. By the time the core whisky arrived in 2021, Raasay had accidentally created an audience for the deconstructed version first.
Now that they’re planning much further ahead, the recipe can evolve with the age of the stock. Alasdair’s near-term goal is to get everything going into the core bottling to at least five years old, while filling and refilling enough casks now to eventually build a 15-year-old Raasay. Fresh Chinkapin that works beautifully at three or five years obviously cannot be treated exactly the same way at fifteen, so refill wood becomes a much bigger part of the planning.
Raasay was designed from day one to make young whisky with enough complexity to work at three years old, but it was never designed to remain a three-year-old whisky forever. We are finally getting to the stage where the original recipe has enough age behind it to show which assumptions were right, which casks needed more time to work their science/magic, and where the recipe will need to flex as the whisky gets older.
Alasdair still reserves about 20% of production for releases outside the core recipe, which has led to Hungarian and Colombian oak, Marsala, different barley varieties, different yeasts, and plenty of single casks. He is selective about where those experiments go, though. Tequila and mezcal casks don’t particularly interest him for the Raasay spirit, and even Tokaji, which he personally loves, isn’t something he thinks would necessarily work here.
That restraint is probably surprising to anyone following Raasay, as Raasay puts out a lot of whisky. Alasdair was candid about balancing the desire to explore with the reality of release fatigue. The core whisky remains about 80% of what they fill for, while special releases give bars, export markets, online customers, and people like me who enjoy unnecessarily complicated side-by-side tastings something new to chase. I have only been able to grab a few of them over the years, and many more in which I had interest slipped past me.
All of this is happening during a fairly ugly period for the whisky industry. Raasay has pulled production back from its maximum capacity and put its proposed Campbeltown distillery on hold again, choosing to keep its attention on the island rather than stretching the business during a downturn. That has a little more weight when you employ such a large percentage of the population around you (about half the island’s workforce).
Alasdair is still looking well past the current cycle, though. When I asked whether Raasay had become a legacy project for him after nearly a decade of distilling, he didn’t really see it that way. He’s thinking about the fifteen-year-old, about what needs to go into cask today to make that possible, and about whatever comes after that. His father gave him an old blending book and told him to do something with it. Apparently “something” turned into an entire distillery, so asking him to stop at this stage may be optimistic.
Isle of Raasay Distillery
If you haven’t joined the Patreon community yet, please consider doing so at patreon.com/whiskeyinmyweddingring
As of November 2026, the $25/month bottle share club level is sold out!
Join at the $5/month level for first shot at an open spot when a member retires and to keep receiving ad-free episodes via Patreon.